NO CHURCH, NO BIBLE: A CENTRAL ARGUMENT
Photo: Pinterest
The "no church, no Bible" argument is a Catholic logical critique of the Protestant doctrine of Sola Scriptura (Bible alone). It asserts that because the Catholic Church historically compiled and canonized the Bible, one cannot logically accept the Bible's authority while rejecting the Church's authority.
Logical Points
Catholics argue that the Bible did not "fall from heaven" but was compiled by the early Church. Key councils like Rome (382), Hippo (393), and Carthage (397) were instrumental in deciding which books were divinely inspired. A common Catholic challenge asks: "How do you know which books belong in the Bible if the Bible itself doesn't list them?". They argue that identifying the canon is a "tradition" that requires an infallible authority outside the Bible. The Church existed for centuries before the New Testament was completed and long before the canon was finalized. Therefore, the Church is the "mother" of the Bible, not its "child". If the Church was fallible when it chose the books of the Bible, then the Bible itself could be flawed or incomplete. To trust the Bible as the infallible Word of God, Catholics argue one must trust the infallible authority of the Church that guaranteed it.
Counter-Response
Following Reformers like John Calvin, some believe the Holy Spirit provides an internal witness to the believer that the scriptures are divine, independent of any church decree. Many Protestants argue that the early Church did not create the authority of the books but simply recognized the inherent authority they already had because they were "God-breathed". Some argue that while God used councils to preserve His Word, those councils are not themselves infallible in all their other teachings.
Reference
Heschmeyer, J. (2023). Is the Bible “Self-Attesting,” or Do We Need the Church? Catholic Answers. https://www.catholic.com/audio/sp/is-the-bible-self-attesting-or-do-we-need-the-church
Rose, D. (2014, March 1). Protestantism’s Old Testament Problem. Catholic Answers. https://www.catholic.com/magazine/print-edition/protestantisms-old-testament-problem
See Also
Comments
Post a Comment